Google Adssearch · pmax · shopping AnalyticsGA4 · GTM Meta Ads Free audit Cases Blog

Blog

Blockbuster Could Have Bought Netflix for $50 Million. It Said No

In 2000 the Netflix founders offered their company to Blockbuster for $50 million. What happened next, and the lesson for a small business owner.

This is the second story in the “Business Stories” series. The first was Kodak, which built a digital camera and went bankrupt, and now it is the turn of American video rental. In the early 2000s Blockbuster had thousands of stores, while Netflix was a small, loss-making service that mailed DVDs to people. The story goes that this was the moment Blockbuster could have picked up its future rival for $50 million.

First, what we rely on. We opened and read five sources: a Newsweek fact-check, a NextTV article of June 3, 2022 with a reply from Blockbuster’s former chief executive, and three filings the company itself made with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC): the annual reports for 2000 and 2004 and the 2010 bankruptcy notice. Whatever these texts do not contain, you will not find here either. Why the executives made the decisions they did, and how things might have gone otherwise, the documents do not say, so we are not going to guess.

2000: an offer for $50 million

Netflix launched in 1998 as a mail-order DVD rental service and was losing money at the time. According to Newsweek, both Netflix co-founders, Reed Hastings and Marc Randolph, confirm that in 2000 they offered their company to Blockbuster for $50 million and were turned down. The magazine rated the story as true.

There is another side. John Antioco, Blockbuster’s CEO at the time, wrote in a LinkedIn post, quoted by NextTV on June 3, 2022, that he was not present at any meeting where the subject came up. In his account, Netflix executives came to pitch a licensing deal and, when the talks stalled, made an off-the-cuff offer to sell their business. His main point is that there were no serious conversations about buying the young Netflix. Antioco also adds that back then nobody, not even the founders themselves, thought Netflix was worth that kind of money.

So we have two versions. The founders say they made the offer and were refused. Blockbuster’s former head says it never came to real negotiations. Yet nobody denies that the offer itself was made: in another post by Antioco, quoted by Newsweek, he says the visitors “apparently offered to sell their company for $50 million”. One small detail for accuracy: NextTV, citing Hastings’ book, dates the meeting to 2002, while Newsweek says 2000.

What Blockbuster earned from

The annual report for 2000 shows the scale. At year end Blockbuster had close to 7,700 stores in the United States and 25 other countries. A separate line in the report covers revenue from rentals that customers kept beyond the initial rental period: $795.8 million, or 16.0% of total revenue. Put simply, roughly one dollar in six the company took came from customers who did not manage to return a tape or disc on time. In its report for 2004 the company explains that such charges are commonly referred to as late fees.

For comparison, a year earlier this line brought in $692.6 million, or 15.5%. The share was growing.

2004: the “end of late fees”

In December 2004 Blockbuster announced the “end of late fees”: from January 1, 2005 the company stopped charging late fees at more than 4,500 company-operated stores and about 550 participating franchise stores in the United States. By the end of 2004 it had approximately 9,100 stores.

The most interesting part of the 2004 report is the company’s own explanation. It writes that dropping these fees will help eliminate the most common customer complaints about renting and stop competitors from using the difference as their own selling point. Among the competitors, the same document names online rental services, Netflix included. In other words, as early as 2004 Blockbuster itself admitted that what annoyed customers most was exactly what brought the company noticeable money, and that rivals were already using it against Blockbuster.

Dropping the fees was not cheap. The company estimated that in 2005 late fees would have brought in $400 million to $450 million of revenue, and it hoped to offset this partly with more store traffic.

One detail is rarely mentioned. Due dates did not disappear: two days or one week, plus a one-week grace period. If a movie still had not come back after that, under the membership agreement it was treated as purchased by the customer. Return it within 30 days and the money was credited back, minus a $1.25 restocking fee. So Blockbuster did not abolish the rule completely; it changed its form.

2010: bankruptcy

On September 23, 2010, Blockbuster Inc. and some of its U.S. subsidiaries filed voluntary petitions under chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code in the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York. The foreign subsidiaries were not part of the filing. Less than six years passed between the “end of late fees” and the court, and about ten since the Netflix offer.

The filing does not explain what exactly brought the company to court. That is why we will not draw a direct line from the bankruptcy to the refused deal or to late fees: the documents make no such connection.

Our takeaway: earning from irritation

From here on this is our opinion, not the content of the documents. If part of your income depends on something that irritates customers, sooner or later someone else will offer the same without it. A competitor does not have to be better at everything. It is enough to remove one thing that makes customers leave you annoyed, and they will remember who did it first.

Small businesses almost always have such things. Someone charges a fee for rescheduling an appointment, someone adds a “service charge” only at the till, somewhere a product return takes three phone calls. Each of these rules once had a reason, and each brings in money. The question is how much it costs you in customers who never came back.

How to check your own business

This is our advice, and the examples below are hypothetical, for illustration.

  1. Gather complaints into one list. Look through your reviews on Google Maps and your messenger chats, and ask your front desk or manager what customers get angry about most often. Look not for “bad service” in general but for specific fees, charges and rules. How to respond to such reviews we covered in “A Bad Google Maps Review: When to Report It and When to Reply”.
  2. Work out how much these fees bring in. Take the figures for the last six months and divide the total of fees and surcharges by your whole revenue. Imagine a salon that earned $10,000 in a month, of which $600 came from late-cancellation fees. That is 6%. Whether that is a lot or a little is up to you, but now you know the exact number.
  3. Picture a competitor who removes it tomorrow. Which of your competitors could write “no rescheduling fees”, and what would you lose if some of your regular customers went over to them? Compare that loss with what the rule itself brings.
  4. Test it small. One location, one product category or one month without the awkward rule. Watch how many customers come back, what the average order is and what people write in reviews, not only how much money disappeared from the fees line.
  5. Do not swap one irritation for another. Remember the grace week at Blockbuster: the rule was changed, not removed. The reports do not say how customers reacted, but if you simply rename a charge, your customers will most likely notice. If you drop a fee, do it honestly and say so plainly.

The point is not to abolish every fee at once. Some of them protect your time and are genuinely needed. What matters is knowing exactly what you earn from and what customers think about it, rather than finding out from a competitor.

Summary

In 2000, according to its founders, Netflix was offered to Blockbuster for $50 million. Blockbuster’s former head denies there were serious negotiations, but not the offer itself. That same year 16% of Blockbuster’s revenue came from movies returned late, in 2005 the company dropped late fees, and in September 2010 it filed for bankruptcy. Apply it to yourself: find what customers complain about, count how much it brings in, and check what happens without it before someone else does.

Next story: a company that was one step from bankruptcy and got out.

Sources

  • Newsweek, fact-check “Fact Check: Did Blockbuster Turn Down Chance to Buy Netflix for $50 Million” (updated 02.02.2022): newsweek.com/fact-check-did-blockbuster-turn-downchance-buy-netflix-50-million-1575557.
  • NextTV, article with John Antioco’s reply (03.06.2022): nexttv.com/news/blockbusters-famous-netflix-2002-rebuff-that-didnt-happen-says-video-chains-former-ceo.
  • Blockbuster Inc., annual report for 2000 (SEC, Form 10-K405): sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1085734/000093066101000794/0000930661-01-000794-0001.txt.
  • Blockbuster Inc., annual report for 2004 (SEC, Form 10-K): sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1085734/000119312505063510/d10k.htm.
  • Blockbuster Inc., current report of 23.09.2010 (SEC, Form 8-K): sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1085734/000119312510215765/d8k.htm.
All articles

Contacts

Let's talk?

Telegram — @exponenta_office_bot Phone — +38 099 314 89 83 Email — [email protected] Mon–Fri 10:00–19:00
Message us on Telegram

The fastest way: the bot logs your request instantly and passes it to the team.

or leave a request

By submitting the form, you agree to the privacy policy.
Telegram